May 18, 2026 0 Blog Yuvraj
Why Energy Crashes Happen After Eating—and How to Prevent Them

It happens at roughly the same time every day. Lunch is finished, the afternoon stretches ahead, and somewhere between 1pm and 3pm the energy simply drains away. The eyelids grow heavy. Concentration dissolves. The simplest tasks feel effortful. You reach for tea or coffee, or simply push through with diminishing returns, waiting for the sensation to pass.

Most people treat this as an inevitable feature of the afternoon — a biological fact of life, like needing sleep at night. Many even have a name for it: the post-lunch slump, the afternoon dip, the 2pm wall.

But it is not inevitable. It is not an unavoidable biological rhythm. It is a specific physiological event — produced by a specific sequence of hormonal and metabolic reactions — that is directly and powerfully influenced by what and how you eat.

Understanding exactly what causes an energy crash after eating — the precise mechanisms, not the vague explanation of "blood sugar" — is what allows you to prevent it. Because once you understand that the crash is caused not by eating per se but by what you eat and how you eat it, the solution becomes obvious and the crash becomes optional.


What an Energy Crash Actually Is: The Physiology

The energy crash that follows a meal is not a single event with a single cause. It is a cascade — a sequence of hormonal and metabolic reactions, each triggered by the one before it, that collectively produce the characteristic experience of post-meal fatigue, brain fog, and reduced motivation.

Understanding this cascade in order is the foundation of understanding how to interrupt it.

Step 1: The Blood Glucose Spike

When a high-glycemic meal is eaten — one dominated by refined carbohydrates like maida-based bread, white rice, sugary chai, packaged biscuits, or processed snacks — glucose is released into the bloodstream rapidly. The rate of glucose appearance in the blood exceeds the body's immediate capacity to use it, and blood glucose rises sharply — often to levels of 140–180 mg/dL or higher in the 30–60 minutes following the meal.

During this spike, most people feel a brief surge of alertness and energy. This is real — glucose is the brain's primary fuel, and a rise in blood glucose immediately translates into improved neural availability of fuel. Some people misinterpret this as the benefit of their meal. It is actually the beginning of the cycle that will produce the crash.

Step 2: The Insulin Surge

As blood glucose rises rapidly, the pancreas releases a correspondingly large amount of insulin to clear the glucose from the bloodstream into cells. The size of the insulin response is proportional to the size of the glucose spike — a large, fast spike produces a large, fast insulin surge.

This insulin surge is doing exactly what it is supposed to do. The problem is not the insulin response itself, but its magnitude and speed — and specifically, what happens when a large insulin response clears blood glucose so efficiently that it overshoots the target.

Step 3: Reactive Hypoglycaemia — The Crash Mechanism

In many people — particularly those with any degree of insulin resistance or who are eating high-glycemic foods regularly — the large, rapid insulin response clears glucose so effectively that blood glucose falls below the pre-meal baseline. This is called reactive hypoglycaemia — a blood glucose drop in reaction to the preceding spike, rather than from insufficient food.

Blood glucose at 80–90 mg/dL is physiologically normal. Blood glucose falling rapidly from 160 to 80 in the space of 90 minutes, however, produces the same neurological experience as blood glucose that is actually low — because the rate of change matters as much as the absolute level. The brain's glucose sensing machinery responds to the speed of the fall as much as the destination, producing the subjective experience of low blood sugar — fatigue, brain fog, irritability, difficulty concentrating, and the overwhelming desire to eat something sugary again.

This is the energy crash. It is not caused by eating too little. It is not caused by the absence of caffeine. It is caused by the blood glucose spike-and-crash cycle that high-glycemic foods reliably produce — and it is entirely preventable by eating in ways that produce a gentler, more sustained glucose release.

Step 4: The Hormonal Pile-On

The reactive hypoglycaemia triggers two additional hormonal responses that compound the energy crash.

Cortisol rises as a counter-regulatory response to the perceived blood glucose emergency. Cortisol's role here is to mobilise glucose from liver glycogen and from muscle tissue through gluconeogenesis — raising blood glucose back to a safe level. But cortisol is also a stress hormone, and its post-meal rise produces the characteristic post-lunch irritability, reduced patience, and difficulty with complex cognitive tasks that many people experience alongside the fatigue. Cortisol's rise also activates ghrelin — the hunger hormone — producing the craving for more carbohydrates that makes the cycle self-reinforcing.

Serotonin rises in response to the carbohydrate-driven insulin spike. Insulin clears not just glucose from the blood but also most large neutral amino acids that compete with tryptophan for transport across the blood-brain barrier. As competing amino acids are cleared, tryptophan's access to the brain is temporarily increased — and tryptophan is the precursor to serotonin. The serotonin rise from a high-carbohydrate meal is calming and mood-elevating in moderate amounts, but in the context of a large carbohydrate load, it contributes to the drowsiness and sedation of the post-meal crash. Serotonin is also the precursor to melatonin — the sleep hormone — providing a direct neurochemical link between the post-meal serotonin surge and the overwhelming sleepiness that follows a large high-carbohydrate lunch.

Step 5: The Digestive Blood Flow Diversion

Beyond hormones, the digestive process itself contributes to post-meal energy reduction through a straightforward physiological mechanism: increased splanchnic blood flow.

After a large meal, the digestive system — the stomach, small intestine, liver, and pancreas — requires significantly increased blood supply to support the absorption and processing of nutrients. The body responds by increasing blood flow to the gut, which requires a corresponding reduction in blood flow elsewhere — including to the peripheral muscles and, to a lesser degree, the brain. This is the mechanism behind the characteristic heaviness and reduced motivation for physical activity that follows a large meal, and it contributes to the cognitive slowdown that accompanies post-meal fatigue.

The magnitude of this effect is directly proportional to meal size. A large meal produces a more significant blood flow diversion than a smaller one — which is why large lunches produce more dramatic energy crashes than moderate-sized ones, even when the glycemic profile is similar.


Why Lunch Produces the Most Consistent Crash

The mid-afternoon energy crash is the most consistent and most dramatic because lunch coincides with two compounding factors that are not present at breakfast or dinner.

The postprandial dip coincides with a genuine circadian trough. Human circadian biology includes a brief, genuine alertness trough in the early-to-mid afternoon — typically between 1pm and 3pm — that is a real feature of the biological clock and is found across human populations globally, including those with no history of napping or afternoon rest. This circadian dip produces a modest natural decline in alertness and core body temperature even in the absence of eating. When a high-glycemic lunch coincides with this circadian window, the two effects compound — producing a crash far more severe than either would produce alone.

The cortisol awakening response has fully dissipated. Cortisol follows a natural daily curve — peaking sharply in the first hour after waking (the cortisol awakening response), which provides the neural energy and motivation of the morning, and declining progressively through the day. By early afternoon, cortisol is at its lowest daytime level — which means the counter-regulatory capacity available to buffer a blood glucose dip is at its daily minimum. The same reactive hypoglycaemia that might be barely noticed at 10am (when cortisol is still relatively elevated) is experienced as a significant crash at 2pm.

The breakfast-to-lunch fuel gap creates a pre-existing depletion. For many people, breakfast is inadequate or skipped, and the energy that sustains the morning comes from cortisol-mediated glycogen release rather than from food. By lunchtime, glycogen stores are partially depleted, the body is primed for a large caloric intake, and the meal that follows is likely to be bigger and higher-glycemic than it would be if breakfast had been adequate — setting up a more dramatic spike-and-crash cycle.


The Foods Most Likely to Cause Energy Crashes

Understanding which specific food categories produce the most dramatic post-meal crashes allows targeted substitution rather than wholesale dietary restriction.

Refined wheat products — the biggest offender in Indian meals. Maida roti, plain white bread, wheat noodles, biscuits as post-lunch "dessert" — these are high-GI carbohydrates that produce rapid, large glucose spikes with no fiber or protein to moderate the response. The typical urban Indian office lunch — two wheat rotis with dal and rice — contains a substantial carbohydrate load delivered primarily in high-GI forms that virtually guarantee a significant post-meal glucose curve.

Polished white rice in large quantities. Rice is a legitimate part of Indian cuisine and not inherently problematic — but white rice consumed in large portions without adequate protein, fiber, and fat produces a significant glucose spike that is a consistent contributor to the post-lunch crash. The portion size matters: a small portion of rice in the context of an otherwise protein-and-fiber-rich meal produces a very different glycemic response than rice as the majority of the meal.

Sweetened beverages with or after meals. Post-meal chai with two teaspoons of sugar, sweetened nimbu pani, packaged fruit drinks alongside lunch — these add a pure sugar load on top of the meal's carbohydrate content, amplifying the spike and therefore the subsequent crash. The timing makes this particularly damaging: glucose from the beverage reaches the bloodstream rapidly, adding to the already-elevated post-meal glucose and producing a higher peak from which the crash is more dramatic.

Low-protein, low-fiber meals. A meal without meaningful protein or fiber is almost entirely glycemic — there is nothing to slow gastric emptying, nothing to moderate glucose absorption, nothing to trigger the sustained satiety hormone response that keeps blood glucose stable. The absence of protein and fiber is as responsible for the post-meal crash as the presence of refined carbohydrates.

Large meal portions. Beyond glycemic index, meal size independently determines crash severity through the blood flow diversion mechanism. A large meal — regardless of composition — produces more dramatic post-meal sedation than a moderate one. Eating to genuine fullness rather than beyond it is one of the simplest structural interventions available for reducing crash severity.


The Foods and Combinations That Prevent Energy Crashes

The foods and eating patterns that prevent energy crashes operate through the same mechanisms in reverse — producing a gentle, sustained glucose curve rather than a spike, triggering sustained satiety hormone responses rather than brief ones, and providing the protein that prevents the reactive cortisol-and-ghrelin cascade.

Each swap in this framework addresses a specific mechanism in the crash cascade — and the swaps work synergistically. Replacing maida with whole millet flattens the glucose curve. Adding protein suppresses ghrelin and stimulates GLP-1. Adding fiber further slows glucose absorption and sustains the satiety hormone response. Replacing refined sugar with jaggery reduces the peak glucose response. Eating more slowly allows the brain's satiety signals — which take approximately 20 minutes to register — to catch up with consumption before the meal is complete. And a protein-rich breakfast stabilises the glucose baseline from which the rest of the day's eating operates.

Together, these changes do not merely reduce the crash — they eliminate it in most people within one to two weeks of consistent implementation.


The Role of Pre-Meal Snacking in Crash Prevention

One of the most effective and counterintuitive strategies for preventing the post-lunch energy crash is the mid-morning snack — eaten two to three hours before lunch, not as a meal replacement but as a metabolic positioning tool.

Here is the mechanism: a protein-and-fiber-rich snack eaten at 10–10:30am does two things that directly affect the post-lunch glycemic response.

First, it prevents the pre-lunch blood glucose dip. Without a mid-morning snack, blood glucose gradually falls through the morning from wherever breakfast left it. By the time lunch arrives at 1pm, blood glucose is at its lowest point of the day — and the person is arriving at lunch with both an elevated ghrelin level and a depleted glycogen baseline. These conditions predict a larger, faster meal — larger portions eaten more quickly — which predicts a more aggressive glucose spike and therefore a more dramatic subsequent crash.

A mid-morning snack maintains blood glucose in a stable range through the morning, so that when lunch arrives, the person is moderately rather than intensely hungry. The resulting meal is eaten more calmly, in a smaller portion, and the glucose response is correspondingly more moderate.

Second, it pre-primes the GLP-1 and PYY satiety hormone response. Research on the second meal effect — a well-documented phenomenon where a low-GI, high-protein pre-meal snack reduces the glycemic and appetite response to the subsequent full meal — shows that the satiety hormones stimulated by the snack partially persist into the next eating occasion, moderating the insulin response and glucose curve from that meal.

This is not a minor effect. Controlled studies comparing identical lunches eaten after a low-GI protein-rich morning snack versus no morning snack show post-lunch glucose responses 15–30% lower in the pre-snacked group — a meaningful reduction in the magnitude of the spike and therefore the magnitude of the subsequent crash.

Nutramore's Jowar Chilla Mix at 30g of protein, Green-Gram Upma Premix at 32g, or even two to three Bajra Moong Chocolate Cookies alongside a small handful of nuts — consumed at 10–10:30am — function as crash prevention tools for the 2pm window as much as they function as nutritional contributions in their own right.


The Post-Lunch Strategy: Managing the Crash Window

For those who cannot immediately overhaul their lunch composition, several immediate strategies reduce the crash in the short term while the dietary transitions are being made.

Walk for 10 minutes after eating. Post-meal walking is one of the most evidence-supported interventions for reducing post-prandial glucose spikes — consistently showing reductions of 20–30% in peak post-meal blood glucose compared to seated rest. The mechanism is direct: muscle contraction activates GLUT4 translocation to cell membranes independently of insulin, increasing glucose uptake into muscle tissue and reducing the blood glucose peak that drives the subsequent crash. A 10-minute walk after lunch requires no equipment, no planning, and no significant time investment — and it directly interrupts the spike-crash mechanism at its root.

Drink water, not sweet beverages, after eating. Sweetened post-meal chai, packaged drinks, or sweetened nimbu pani add a pure glucose load on top of the meal's carbohydrate, amplifying the spike. Plain water, unsweetened jeera water, or herbal teas support digestion without metabolic interference.

Choose a low-GI afternoon snack, not caffeine, as the first intervention when the crash hits. The instinctive response to a 2pm energy crash is another cup of tea or coffee — caffeine, which provides a brief alertness boost by blocking adenosine receptors but does nothing to address the underlying blood glucose instability and may worsen it by elevating cortisol. A small, protein-and-fiber-containing snack at the moment the crash begins — addressing the reactive hypoglycaemia directly with a low-GI carbohydrate and protein combination — produces more stable and lasting energy recovery than caffeine.

Nutramore's Millet Methi Crispies or Baked Protein Sticks eaten at the first sign of the afternoon crash provide low-GI complex carbohydrates that gently raise blood glucose without spiking it, alongside protein that suppresses ghrelin and cortisol, and fiber (including fenugreek's galactomannan in the Methi Crispies) that sustains the glucose recovery rather than producing another spike-crash cycle from the rescue snack itself.


Breakfast: The Most Powerful Crash Prevention Tool

Of all the dietary interventions available for preventing the post-lunch energy crash, breakfast protein is the most powerful and the most consistently supported by research — because it sets the metabolic baseline from which every subsequent meal's glucose response operates.

A high-protein breakfast — 25–35g of protein — produces several cascade effects that persist through the day:

It suppresses ghrelin through the morning, so lunch is approached from a position of moderate rather than intense hunger. It stimulates GLP-1 that partially persists through the morning, improving insulin sensitivity at lunch. It establishes a stable blood glucose baseline by preventing the morning glucose dip that compels large, fast, high-glycemic lunches. And it supports the serotonin precursor availability that prevents the mid-afternoon serotonin surge from a high-carbohydrate lunch from reaching the levels that produce sedation.

Research published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition has demonstrated that a high-protein breakfast (35g of protein) significantly reduces total daily caloric intake, reduces post-lunch blood glucose variability, and reduces the frequency and severity of afternoon energy crashes compared to low-protein breakfasts or skipped breakfast — effects that persisted throughout the full day and that were mediated through the ghrelin and GLP-1 pathways described above.

Nutramore's Green-Gram Upma Premix at 32g of protein — from whole green gram with intrinsic fiber and low GI — and Jowar Chilla Mix at 30g are among the highest-protein Indian breakfast options available in a format that prepares in under ten minutes. Their protein content is not incidental — it is specifically calibrated to meet the 25–35g threshold that research identifies as the most effective dose for reducing afternoon energy crash frequency.

The Breakfast Premix Combo — combining Green-Gram Upma, Jowar Upma, and Jowar Chilla Mix across the week — provides this protein foundation across three different flavour profiles and textures, maintaining the variety that makes a consistent breakfast habit sustainable rather than monotonous.


Meal Composition: How to Structure Lunch to Prevent the Crash

For those whose lunch is prepared at home or where composition can be influenced, the structural principles of a crash-preventing lunch are specific and practical.

Lead with fiber or protein, not carbohydrate. The order in which foods are consumed within a meal significantly affects the post-meal glucose response. Research by Alpana Shukla at Weill Cornell Medicine has demonstrated that consuming vegetables and protein before the carbohydrate component of an identical meal reduces the post-meal glucose peak by 37% and the insulin response by 57% compared to eating the carbohydrate first. Starting with dal or sabzi before roti or rice — a simple sequence change requiring no substitution of ingredients — produces a meaningfully gentler glucose curve from the same meal.

Ensure the carbohydrate is as low-GI as possible. Jowar roti instead of wheat roti. Brown or red rice instead of white. Dal-based rice dishes rather than plain rice. The gradual introduction of whole millets as the primary carbohydrate base — not all at once, but progressively — is among the highest-leverage single changes available for reducing post-meal crash frequency.

Include adequate protein. A meal without 15–20g of protein produces a more pronounced crash than the same meal with adequate protein — because protein is required to stimulate the GLP-1 and PYY satiety responses that moderate the glucose curve and prevent the reactive hypoglycaemia. Dal, curd, paneer, eggs, or a protein-rich starter provide this.

Keep portion size moderate. The post-meal blood flow diversion that contributes to crash-related fatigue is directly proportional to meal size. A meal that leaves you comfortably satisfied rather than full — which the protein and fiber content of a well-composed meal makes easier to achieve at a lower total volume — produces less post-meal sedation through the blood flow diversion mechanism.


The Magnesium Connection: A Nutrient Most People Are Missing

Beyond the macronutrient and glycemic considerations, magnesium deficiency plays a specific and underappreciated role in post-meal energy crashes.

Magnesium is a cofactor for more than 300 enzymatic reactions, including those governing glucose metabolism, ATP production, and insulin receptor signalling. In the context of energy crashes specifically, magnesium's role in mitochondrial ATP synthesis is most directly relevant — the mitochondria's capacity to convert glucose into usable cellular energy (ATP) depends on magnesium at multiple enzymatic steps. Magnesium-deficient cells are less efficient at converting glucose to ATP, which means that even when blood glucose is adequate, the cellular energy production from that glucose is suboptimal — contributing to the fatigue and brain fog that characterise the post-meal crash.

Magnesium deficiency is extremely common in the modern Indian diet, where the displacement of magnesium-rich whole grains and legumes by refined alternatives has removed the primary dietary sources of this mineral. Bajra is among the richest dietary sources of magnesium available in Indian cuisine, containing approximately 130–140mg per 100g — comparable to many nuts and significantly higher than wheat.

Nutramore's Bajra Cookies and Bajra Moong Chocolate Cookies provide bajra's magnesium contribution alongside their low-GI, fiber-rich, jaggery-sweetened profile — making them effective tools for the afternoon snack window not only through their glycemic and protein properties but through the magnesium contribution that supports the cellular energy metabolism at the root of the crash experience.


The Iron Connection: Why Women Experience More Severe Crashes

For women — particularly those with iron deficiency, which affects more than 50% of Indian women of reproductive age — energy crashes after eating have an additional physiological dimension beyond blood glucose.

Iron is essential for haemoglobin — the protein in red blood cells that carries oxygen. In iron deficiency, haemoglobin production is impaired, reducing the oxygen-carrying capacity of the blood. Every cell in the body requires oxygen for ATP production through oxidative phosphorylation. When oxygen delivery is reduced by iron deficiency, cellular energy production is impaired — producing the fatigue and brain fog that iron-deficient women experience chronically, and that is particularly noticeable in the post-meal window when blood flow is being partially diverted to the digestive system and the remaining circulation must support peripheral tissue function with reduced oxygen-carrying capacity.

Iron deficiency fatigue is often most pronounced in the afternoon — because the physical demands of the morning have partially depleted the limited iron-dependent oxygen transport capacity, leaving less reserve for the afternoon's cognitive demands.

Bajra's iron content — approximately 8mg per 100g, among the highest of any grain — makes bajra-based snacks genuinely supportive for iron-deficient women experiencing afternoon energy crashes. Pairing bajra-containing snacks with a vitamin C source (a piece of amla, a squeeze of lime, a piece of guava) enhances iron absorption from the non-haem source — a practical, consistent strategy for building iron status through regular snacking rather than requiring supplementation.


Building an Energy-Stable Day: The Complete Framework

Bringing everything together into a practical daily structure:

Breakfast (7–8am) — Protein Foundation: Jowar Chilla or Green-Gram Upma — 30–32g of complete protein, low GI, high fiber. Sets the glucose baseline and ghrelin suppression that determines the rest of the day's energy stability.

Mid-morning snack (10–10:30am) — Second Meal Effect Activation: Two to three Bajra Moong Chocolate Cookies or Moong Almond Pistachio Cookies alongside a small handful of nuts. Low GI, protein-containing, fiber-rich. Pre-primes the GLP-1 response for lunch and prevents the pre-lunch glucose dip that drives large, crash-inducing meals.

Lunch (1–1:30pm) — Crash-Proof Composition: Lead with dal or sabzi. Include jowar or bajra roti if available, or moderated portions of rice with substantial dal. Adequate protein, adequate fiber, moderate portion. Walk for 10 minutes after eating.

Early afternoon snack (3:30–4pm) — Crash Window Interception: Millet Methi Crispies or Baked Protein Sticks — or Ragi Chocolate Cookies for those preferring something sweet. This snack intercepts the crash before it fully develops, providing low-GI carbohydrates that gently restore blood glucose, protein that suppresses ghrelin and cortisol, and fiber that sustains the recovery rather than creating another spike.

Dinner (7–8pm) — Finish Eating Early: Protein-centred, moderate carbohydrate, high vegetable content. Complete at least 2–3 hours before sleep to allow digestive settling and prevent the late-night eating cycle that disrupts the next morning's glucose baseline.

This structure eliminates the conditions that produce post-meal crashes at every point in the cascade: the pre-meal blood glucose dip, the meal composition that causes the spike, the absence of the morning snack that pre-activates satiety hormones, and the absence of the afternoon snack that intercepts the crash before it becomes debilitating.


Why Coffee Is Not the Answer — and What to Do Instead

The most common response to an energy crash is coffee or tea — and it is worth being explicit about why this is a limited solution and what the better alternative looks like.

Caffeine works by blocking adenosine receptors in the brain. Adenosine is a neurotransmitter that accumulates during waking hours and produces the progressive feeling of tiredness that drives sleep. By blocking adenosine receptors, caffeine temporarily prevents the brain from registering this accumulated tiredness — producing an alertness that feels like energy but is actually a suppression of the tiredness signal rather than a genuine restoration of metabolic energy.

This distinction matters for the post-meal crash specifically because the crash is not primarily caused by accumulated adenosine — it is caused by reactive hypoglycaemia, hormonal shifts, and in the case of iron or magnesium deficiency, impaired cellular energy production. Caffeine addresses none of these root causes. It briefly masks the symptom while the underlying blood glucose instability continues — and when the caffeine wears off 3–4 hours later, both the original adenosine load and any unresolved blood glucose instability will be experienced simultaneously, producing an afternoon fatigue that is often worse than the original crash.

Additionally, caffeine consumed after 2pm has a documented negative effect on sleep quality — specifically reducing slow-wave sleep depth and efficiency — which impairs the next morning's glucose baseline and insulin sensitivity, creating the conditions for a more severe crash the following day.

The better response to a 2pm energy crash is a small, low-GI protein-and-fiber snack — addressing the reactive hypoglycaemia that is the primary cause of the crash, rather than masking the symptom while leaving the cause in place. A single cup of unsweetened tea alongside the snack is a reasonable compromise that provides the sensory satisfaction of the tea ritual without the pure glucose addition of the sweetened version or the large caffeine load that disrupts sleep.


Final Thoughts

Energy crashes after eating are not inevitable. They are not a fixed feature of human physiology or a simple consequence of eating lunch. They are the predictable, specific result of eating in ways that produce large, rapid blood glucose spikes — followed by large insulin surges, reactive hypoglycaemia, cortisol and ghrelin rebounds, and the hormonal cascade that produces fatigue, brain fog, and the afternoon slump that disrupts productivity and wellbeing for millions of people every day.

Every component of this cascade is addressable through food — specifically, through the choice of whole, low-GI millets and pulses over refined carbohydrates, the inclusion of protein at every eating occasion, the fiber that sustains satiety hormone responses, the minerals that support cellular energy metabolism, and the meal timing that prevents the extreme hunger and glycemic volatility that drive crash-producing meals.

The afternoon that follows a jowar chilla breakfast and a bajra-moong mid-morning snack is a different afternoon from the one that follows a white bread breakfast and a maida biscuit mid-morning. The difference is not subtle. It is the difference between working through the afternoon with sustained focus and working through it against a biological tide of hormones and metabolic signals that are actively working against cognitive function.

That difference is available — consistently, predictably, and starting with the next meal.


Explore Nutramore's full range of energy-stabilising millet snacks at nutramore.in/our-products

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *